It may seem complicated but exempt vs. nonexempt employees doesn’t have to be. There are certain requirements that can help you categorize employees. Let’s break it down.

Note: This is not legal advice. Please consult with a lawyer for your specific situational advice.

Definition of Exempt vs Nonexempt Employees

Exempt Employees:

Exempt employees tend to be salaried individuals who are excluded from the Fair Labor Standards Act’s (FLSA) overtime rules. Thus, they are not eligible for extra pay, regardless of how many hours they work in a week (such as overtime) unless stated in the contract or benefits package. The Department of Labor has outlined how exemption status affects certain industries and overtime. 

Common Examples:

Executive managers like CEOs, experts with an advanced understanding of subjects such as law or medicine, and certain creative workers such as artists or writers.

Nonexempt Employees:

Employees who are nonexempt are individuals who are covered by the FLSA’s minimum wage and overtime regulations. They are normally paid hourly and are entitled to overtime pay if they work more than 40 hours per week. These are fairly common in small businesses.

Common Examples:

There is a wide spectrum of nonexempt employees as most people fall under this category. Common examples include clerical staff, technicians, customer service representatives, blue-collar workers, and many others.

Key Differences Between Exempt vs Nonexempt Employees

Exempt:

• Fixed Salary: Exempt employees are paid a set sum each pay period that does not vary dependent on the quality or quantity of work accomplished.
• No Overtime: Unless stipulated in a benefits or bonus package, exempt employees do not qualify for overtime.

Nonexempt:

• Hourly Wage: Wages are based on the actual hours employee’s work. Their pay can vary each pay period due to the hours worked.
• Overtime: Employees are entitled to overtime pay if they work over 40 hours in a week, which is usually calculated as one and a half times their regular hourly wage.

Benefits & Perks

• Exempt: Due to their often-higher-level roles, exempt employees may receive more comprehensive benefits. As an example, a CEO could receive more generous retirement contributions, a higher level of health insurance, or stock options and bonuses.

• Nonexempt: While they are eligible for conventional benefits such as health insurance and paid time off, employee options may be limited in comparison to those available to exempt employees. The clear advantage, however, is the overtime compensation they receive, which can greatly increase their wages.

	Exempt Employees	Nonexempt Employees
Pros for Employers	Flexibility: No need to track hourly work or pay overtime.   Consistent Salaries: Easier budgeting and payroll processes.   Higher Responsibility: Often in managerial or specialized roles.	Cost-Effective: Pay only for actual hours worked.   Overtime Control: Can limit access to overtime to control costs.   Flexible Scheduling: Easier to adjust shifts as needed.
Cons for Employers	Higher Salaries: Typically earn more than nonexempt employees. Benefits: Might expect more comprehensive benefits.   Legal Risks: Misclassification can lead to legal consequences.	Overtime Costs: Can add up if employees frequently work extra hours.   Time Tracking: Need systems in place to track hours accurately.   Legal Compliance: Must adhere strictly to labor laws.
Pros for Employees	Stable Income: Regular and consistent salary.   Benefits: Often receive comprehensive benefits.   Career Growth: Typically in roles with more growth potential.	Overtime Pay: Earn extra for working beyond standard hours.   Defined Hours: Clearer work-life boundaries.   Legal Protections: Stronger rights under labor laws.
Cons for Employees	Longer Hours: Might work beyond standard hours without extra pay.   High Responsibility: Greater job pressures and responsibilities.	Lower Base Pay: Typically earn less than exempt counterparts.   Less Flexibility: Strict start and end times.   Limited Benefits: Might receive fewer benefits than exempt employees.

Legal Standards You Need to Know

Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)

The FLSA is a U.S. labor law that establishes minimum wage, overtime pay, and youth employment standards. The act establishes certain criteria for assessing whether an employee is exempt or nonexempt. Misclassification, whether deliberate or unintentional, can have serious legal consequences for companies.

State Labor Laws

State labor laws are a bit more complicated. Each state has its own labor laws that can affect employees and how you pay them. These laws can mirror/enhance the FLSA or carve out specific procedures. Compliance with federal regulations isn’t enough. Often, state-specific guidelines change annually or even more frequently, so employers must also be aware of and follow them.

3 Tips for Employers

Regular Reviews: Companies should periodically conduct regular reviews of HR employees’ roles, responsibilities, and compensation to ensure they’re classified correctly.

Seek Expertise: Labor laws can be complex. Consult HR professionals, legal counsel, or labor experts to ensure compliance. An ounce of prevention can save a pound of cure.

Training: Ensure that management and human resources professionals are well-trained and up to speed on federal and state labor rules. This can help to avoid unintended misclassifications and penalties.

Looking for a Payroll Provider?

Looking for a payroll provider to help you with these problems and more? Need payroll software to simplify this process? Don’t worry, we’ve got your back! 360Connect can help you connect with suppliers to help you with payroll. Just fill out our 1–2-minute form and we’ll contact you to verify your information. From there, you can relax and watch as up to 5 quotes roll in. It’s that simple!